AdvertiseDonate
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Big-city news, all in one place.
Hot News Report · 835 Hanover Street, Suite 201, Manchester, NH 03104

Expert witness in Letby trial used in other case while barred from treating patients

A doctor barred from treating patients during the Lucy Letby trial also served as an expert witness in the prosecution of two Birmingham parents, raising questions about expert disclosure rules.

By Yuki Melnyk ·

Illustration for: Expert witness in Letby trial used in other case while barred from treating patients
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Professor Peter Hindmarsh, a medical expert whose testimony helped convict nurse Lucy Letby, was instructed in a separate prosecution while his hospital had barred him from treating patients. The Guardian revealed this week that University College London Hospitals (UCLH) excluded Hindmarsh from clinical practice in March 2023. This exclusion occurred during the main Letby trial, yet the jury that convicted her five months later was never informed of the restriction.

Hindmarsh subsequently produced a critical expert report in August 2023 for the Crown Prosecution Service. The report supported charges against Damion and Tamara Thomas, two parents in Birmingham accused of neglecting their twelve-year-old son, Joshua, before his death. Joshua had suffered from diabetes, and Hindmarsh concluded that the symptoms were clear enough that medical help should have been sought earlier.

In March 2026, Tamara Thomas was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect. She received a sentence of three years and nine months in prison. Her husband, Damion, was found not guilty of manslaughter but guilty of neglect, receiving a sentence of two years and nine months. The parents have applied to the Court of Appeal for permission to appeal their convictions.

The lead investigator, Vicki Harris, highlighted the importance of Hindmarsh’s opinion, stating that expert evidence showed the child’s death would have been preventable with earlier medical attention. Alessandro Thomas, the couple’s son and representative, noted that the family was unaware of the General Medical Council’s investigation or the safety concerns regarding Hindmarsh’s practice during the two and a half years of his involvement.

UCLH excluded Hindmarsh because it could not accept the level of risk he posed to children and young people. A medical director reported to the GMC that Hindmarsh had breached a supervision order and advised two child patients to stop taking insulin at home. Despite this, Hindmarsh did not appear to inform West Midlands police of the investigation when he wrote his report for the Thomas case.

The CPS West Midlands region remained unaware of the serious concerns until December 2025, when Hindmarsh finally disclosed the details. Although the CPS independently discovered the GMC restrictions in November 2025, they decided to continue relying on his expertise for the prosecution. This decision has raised questions about the use of expert witnesses in courts.

Joshua Thomas, who had been unwell with respiratory problems since mid-November 2022, became critically ill on December 9. His parents were accused of failing to recognize symptoms of diabetes, a condition his father also had. Hindmarsh’s report focused on the child’s symptoms at 4 am, arguing that a medical assessment should have been sought at that time.

Hindmarsh described himself in his report as a consultant in pediatric endocrinology with extensive experience. However, at the time, UCLH was not permitting him to work as a consultant. The jury in the Thomas trial was never told that UCLH had lost confidence in his professional judgment regarding insulin and diabetes.

Legal rules require experts to disclose anything that might undermine their opinion or credibility. Tim Green KC, a disclosure specialist, noted that this duty requires disclosure as soon as reasonably practicable. Hindmarsh’s late disclosure, occurring more than two years after his report, has led to scrutiny over his compliance with these rules.

The GMC investigation into Hindmarsh never reached a final conclusion. He was granted voluntary erasure from the medical register in November 2024, which ended the investigation. In a self-certificate provided to the Thomas defense, Hindmarsh mentioned previous tribunal rulings but did not detail the UCLH exclusion or the specific concerns reported to the regulator. He stated that no matters were proven against him, as the decision to erase his registration brought the investigation to a close.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Hot News Report in your inboxBig-city news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Hot News Report in your inboxBig-city news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.