MLS Playoff Round 1: Analysts Predict Upsets and Favorites in Conference Semifinal Bids
ESPN analysts predict outcomes for the 16-team MLS playoff field, highlighting key players and tactical matchups in the conference first round.
By Yuki Melnyk ·

The Major League Soccer postseason has narrowed to 16 clubs following Thursday night's wild card round, which eliminated Orlando City and the Seattle Sounders. These teams will join 14 other clubs in the first round of the conference playoffs, a best-of-three series that begins on Saturday, November 21, 2026. If any of the matchups require a decisive third game, those contests will be played on December 2, 2026. ESPN soccer analysts Jeff Carlisle and Joseph Lowery, along with other staff members, have broken down the Eastern and Western Conference matchups to predict which teams will advance to the semifinals.
In the Eastern Conference, Nashville SC is set to face FC Cincinnati in a matchup between the top seed and the ninth seed. Nashville, which posted the best regular season record in MLS history, is led by German forward Hany Mukhtar. The German international is the league's leader in goal contributions and has scored at least 15 goals in five of his six full campaigns in the league. Analysts believe that slowing down Mukhtar and his partner Sam Surridge will be the key factor for Cincinnati, who will look to leverage the form of striker Kevin Denkey. Denkey missed the wild card win over Orlando due to international duty but is expected to be fresh and ready for this series. Most analysts predict a Nashville victory, citing the team's balance and historic regular season performance.
Inter Miami will host Columbus Crew in another highly anticipated clash. Lionel Messi is expected to become the first player in MLS history to win three MVP awards, having also claimed the Golden Boot and led the league in goal contributions this year. The Argentine forward remains the central focus for Miami, despite a change in the supporting cast since the previous season's title run. Columbus, which underwent a significant summer overhaul, has found new form with Spanish midfielder Brais Méndez. The former Real Sociedad playmaker has emerged as the Crew's primary offensive threat. Analysts are divided on the outcome, but many note that while Columbus has shown defensive resilience, the sheer talent of Miami, including Messi, Luis Suárez, and Rodrigo De Paul, gives them the edge in this series.
The New England Revolution will face the Philadelphia Union in a contest defined by contrasting styles. New England, under first-year manager Marko Mitrovic, has shown strong defensive organization, allowing only one fast break goal since the World Cup break. They also benefit from the elite shot-stopping of goalkeeper Matt Turner, who delivered the best single-season campaign in the club's MLS history. Philadelphia, meanwhile, is powered by young winger Cavan Sullivan, who was an MVP finalist and has been elite in the final third. The Union have been dominant since the mid-season break, boasting a long unbeaten run. Analysts generally favor Philadelphia, believing their attacking momentum and the impact of Sullivan will overcome New England's defensive solidity.
In the final Eastern Conference matchup, the Chicago Fire will face Charlotte FC. The Fire welcomed Robert Lewandowski over the summer, and the 38-year-old striker has contributed 13 goals in the second half of the season. However, analysts note that the team's overall statistics have declined since his arrival compared to the first half of the year. Charlotte FC, led by Spanish playmaker Pep Biel, has shown clinical efficiency in the final third. Biel, who led the team in goal contributions for the second straight season, is viewed as the best player in the club's history. Predictions are split, with some analysts favoring Chicago's star power and others backing Charlotte's consistent attacking output and defensive improvements.
In the Western Conference, the Vancouver Whitecaps will take on Real Salt Lake. Vancouver features veteran forward Brian White, who scored a career-high 20 goals this season. Although World Cup winner Thomas Müller has been limited by injury, White's clinical finishing makes him a primary threat. Real Salt Lake, who advanced past Seattle in the wild card round, will rely on their goalkeeper Rafael Cabral to deliver another standout performance. The Crew's frontline is potent, but analysts believe Vancouver's consistency and elite status, having recorded over 60 points in back-to-back seasons, give them a significant advantage in this series.
As the playoffs progress, the focus shifts to these high-stakes best-of-three series. The combination of veteran stars and emerging talents will determine which teams advance. Fans can expect intense competition as the 16 remaining clubs fight for a spot in the conference semifinals. The first games are scheduled for this weekend, with the potential for a third game on December 2 if necessary.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






