Providence Council approves Flock camera ban with 10 to 4 vote
The ordinance requires a second reading in early December before heading to Mayor Brett Smiley, who has not ruled out a veto.
By Yuki Melnyk ·

Providence city councilors voted 10 to 4 on Thursday night to ban automatic license-plate readers, a measure that requires a second passage before reaching Mayor Brett Smiley's desk.
The 10 affirmative votes constitute a two-thirds majority, ensuring the ban can survive a potential veto from the mayor, who supports the technology.
The ordinance covers all brands of license-plate cameras, including the 60 units currently deployed by the Providence Police Department.
These devices photograph vehicles as they pass, building a searchable database for law enforcement and allowing for proactive alerts when a target vehicle is detected.
The ban excludes five cameras installed by the Rhode Island State Police on Interstate 95, Route 146, and Route 6.
Councilor Sue AnderBois, who led the push for the ban, cited data privacy concerns. She noted that the data resides on company servers, meaning the city lacks full control over resident information.
"A lot of our concern with Flock and a number of the other companies who are coming in to do that same kind of work, is that the data lives on their servers, and so we do not control the data," AnderBois said.
Providence Police Chief Oscar Perez, who announced his retirement this week, argued the cameras have significantly improved crime-solving capabilities. Deputy Chief Timothy O'Hara told a recent hearing that the technology contributed to a "historic drop in crimes" over the past three years.
"We need every legal advantage to keep this city safe," O'Hara said. "We believe here in Providence we have the proper safeguards in place to protect the confidentiality of our information."
Police cited the Brown University mass shooting in December 2025 as a key example, where Flock data helped solve the case after a tip about the suspect's vehicle.
AnderBois countered that the cameras did not prevent the deaths in that incident, noting the suspect killed an MIT professor and himself before police located him.
"This would be a better example of how Flock works to save us if it had saved the gentleman he murdered in Cambridge," she said. She also criticized Flock for using the tragedy for financial benefit, calling it "gross." Councilman Pedro Espinal, who voted against the ban, acknowledged the privacy concerns but emphasized the need for public safety tools. "If something were to happen to one of my kids, I want to make sure that whoever hurts my family is going to get caught," Espinal said. The council is expected to hold a second vote on the ordinance in early December. If passed, Mayor Smiley will decide whether to sign the ban or issue a veto.






