Survivor and legal experts urge review of consent laws after drug-facilitated rape case
Following the conviction of four men in a drug-facilitated rape case, legal experts and campaigners are urging the government to review consent laws and clarify that third parties cannot consent on a victim's behalf.
By Elena Greco ·

Campaigners and legal professionals have responded to a call for a thorough review of consent legislation following the high-profile trial of Joanne Young. The survivor, who was drugged and raped by her former husband, emphasized the need to address broader issues surrounding sexual assault. While the law is currently under scrutiny, advocates argue that action must extend beyond specific statutory changes to include a deeper societal understanding of what constitutes valid consent.
Joanne Young, 49, waived her right to anonymity after her former husband, Philip Young, pleaded guilty earlier this year to dozens of abuse charges. At Winchester Crown Court, jurors learned that Philip Young, a former Conservative councillor, had advertised his wife on dating and swinging websites. He presented the arrangement as a mutual kink, but in reality, he had been sedating her to an inanimate state where she could not resist. Four men who answered the adverts were convicted on Thursday of sexual offences against her.
Speaking after the convictions, Joanne Young stated that no one should be able to give consent on behalf of another person. Her daughter, Alex Young, echoed this sentiment, calling for a legal change to explicitly prevent third-party consent from being used as a defense in court. Both women highlighted the confusion caused by the defense arguments presented during the trial, which suggested that the victims had effectively consented through their husband's instructions.
Kate Parker, a criminal barrister and founder of the Schools Consent Project, noted that current legislation does not explicitly state that third-party consent is a valid defense. She explained that the Sexual Offences Act 2003 does not include this provision. Instead, defense counsel often argue that the defendant genuinely and reasonably believed the victim was consenting. Parker argued that while defendants should be able to explain their state of mind, juries need to become more aware that consent cannot be effectively outsourced to a third party.
The trial revealed that the four convicted men, who were strangers to one another, failed to seek consent from Joanne Young before engaging in sexual activity. They claimed they had been deceived by Philip Young and believed she was consenting. Parker expressed hope that as public knowledge of the law improves, these types of arguments will carry less weight with juries. She believes that increased awareness will prevent defendants from claiming legal safety based solely on a third party's assurance.
Harriet Wistrich, a solicitor and director of the Centre for Women's Justice, pointed out that the jury in this case ultimately rejected the defense. She argued that it should be obvious in the law that one person cannot consent on another's behalf, but making this explicit could strengthen the legal framework. Wistrich acknowledged that defense barristers have a duty to robustly defend their clients, but she cautioned against relying on myths or stereotypes that overstep the legal boundaries of consent.
Ciara Bergman, chief executive of Rape Crisis England & Wales, agreed that the law warrants scrutiny. She referenced the Sexual Offences Act 2003, which defines consent as agreeing by choice with the freedom and capacity to make that choice. Bergman stated that the existing law is clear but is often misinterpreted and misapplied by defendants, barristers, and juries. She emphasized that consent is specific, ongoing, and dependent on the situation, meaning an unconscious person cannot consent.
Bergman also highlighted that drugging someone is the opposite of consent. She noted a growing recognition in organized drug-facilitated abuse cases of the specific attraction some perpetrators have to a victim's inability to consent. Prof Miranda Horvath, director of the Institute for Social Justice and Crime at the University of Suffolk, added that incorrect beliefs about consent must be robustly challenged. She stressed the importance of clear education for all age groups, noting that a lack of understanding cannot be an acceptable excuse for rape.
Jess Phillips, a Labour MP, suggested the government should test whether the law can be tightened to assert more clearly that consent cannot come from a third party. She argued that if the law were stricter, defendants in cases like this might have pleaded guilty, sparing the victim the trauma of a trial. A spokesperson for the Ministry of Justice confirmed that the law is clear on the matter and that the criminal law is kept under review to determine what more can be done to protect victims.






