Joanne Young's case highlights progress in UK justice system, but challenges remain
While a new suspect-centric approach in prosecution signals progress for rape victims, court backlogs and persistent myths suggest the justice system still has a long way to go.
By Yuki Melnyk ·

Joanne Young expressed relief for herself, her family, and future victims after standing outside Winchester crown court on Thursday. She had waived her anonymity to speak about years of drugging and rape by her husband, who had invited other men to assault her. Young stated that she hoped her case would encourage women and girls who have suffered similar abuse to believe they can be understood and taken seriously by the criminal justice system.
While Young’s dignified address drew significant attention, a separate statement made by a prosecutor on the same day carried profound significance for legal reformers. James Foster, a specialist prosecutor in the Crown Prosecution Service’s Wessex complex casework unit, explained that the case was built using a suspect-centric approach. He noted that this method allowed the prosecution to prove to the jury that Philip Young could not provide consent on behalf of the victim, and that each defendant played a part in the sexual abuse.
The term suspect-centric is not new, yet its routine use in rape and domestic abuse cases was rare until recently. For decades, investigations and prosecutions in such cases often focused heavily on the victim rather than the accused. Foster’s comments represent a shift that would have seemed unlikely just a decade ago, offering a sign of real change to those who have long advocated for reform in how these crimes are handled.
This progress follows a period of significant concern regarding the handling of sexual offense cases. In 2018, reporting revealed a sharp decline in the number of cases prosecutors were willing to take to trial. Prosecutions fell by 60 percent from 5,190 in 2016-17 to 2,102 in 2019-20, even as police received more incident reports. At that time, training events for prosecutors reportedly advised removing weak cases from the system to improve conviction rates.
The situation prompted a government review launched in March 2019. When the findings were released in 2021, the conclusion was that victims were often made to feel as though they were the ones under investigation. The then government, which had overseen a 30 percent reduction in CPS staff and the loss of approximately 20,000 police officers, issued a frank apology. Justice Secretary Robert Buckland expressed deep regret, while Policing and Crime Minister Kit Malthouse admitted the system had simply not been good enough.
In response, the Home Office funded Operation Soteria Bluestone, led by academics Betsy Stanko and Katrin Hohl. The initiative reviewed cases across several police forces to identify failures. Officers and prosecutors were directed to change practices in six key areas. These included focusing investigations on suspects, disrupting repeat offenders, and engaging more effectively with victims. They were also instructed to improve training, officer wellbeing, and the use of digital forensics, while stopping the indiscriminate collection of victims’ personal data.
These changes have been encouraged by Sarah Crew, the newly created police lead for rape in England and Wales. By 2024, police referrals and CPS charges for rape had returned to levels seen in 2016. This recovery has been praised by independent sexual violence advisers, including Rape Crisis England & Wales. However, charities warn against complacency, noting that approximately 97 percent of reported rapes still do not reach court.
Concerns remain that the progress could stall due to a significant backlog in the courts. Rape survivors are currently waiting an average of 423 days for trial, with many waiting much longer. Additionally, experts argue that rape myths persist in courtrooms. During the trial of Russell Brand, who was sentenced to more than 10 years in prison after being found guilty of rape and sexual assault, his barrister argued that the accusers had not resisted, screamed, or tried to leave.
Katrin Hohl, now the government’s independent adviser on rape, has expressed concern that the courts are not keeping pace with improvements in police and prosecution practices. Last month, she published a report suggesting that cases prepared under the new, higher standards hit a cliff edge once they reach trial. Despite the difficulties, Young’s experience offers a glimpse of hope in a system that has historically failed many victims, though the work to fully transform it remains far from complete.






