Juror describes buckle test in murder case
An anonymous juror from the Matthew Farwell trial detailed the specific physical and digital evidence that swayed the panel toward a guilty verdict.
By Yuki Melnyk ·

A juror in the Stoughton murder trial of former police officer Matthew Farwell has described the specific physical test that helped convince the jury of his guilt. The anonymous man, who spoke to NBC10 Boston on condition that his face remain hidden, said the panel focused intensely on the buckle attached to the strap found around Sandra Birchmore's neck. That metal clasp had left a deep wound on Birchmore's chest, a detail that distinguished the injury from a typical struggle.
During deliberations, one juror volunteered to press the clasp against his own arm to gauge the force required to create such a mark. "See how hard you can get it, see how much of a mark it makes," the juror recalled the volunteer saying. The experiment aimed to determine if the injury resulted from a violent scuffle or if Birchmore took her own life. The result was clear to the panel. "It made a small, small little mark, but nothing compared to the mark that was on her chest," the juror said.
Beyond the physical evidence, the jury weighed digital records from the night of the incident. Farwell's twin brother, who had a sexual relationship with Birchmore and was granted immunity to testify, provided a candid assessment of his sibling's actions. "I couldn't believe my brother was that stupid to do this," the brother reportedly told the court. The juror noted that the panel shared that sentiment. Birchmore's cellphone going cold before Farwell left her Canton apartment also played a role in the decision.
Video footage from that night further solidified the jury's position. The recording showed Farwell entering the apartment wearing a mask. "Him going into the apartment with the mask on, that was a big thing," the juror said. He pointed to other evidence suggesting Farwell did not want to wear the mask, implying a premeditated effort to hide his identity.
The jury initially reported being deadlocked after the first day of deliberations. The juror clarified that this status meant they could not reach a verdict by the end of the day, not that they were permanently stuck. The panel returned to its deliberations and reached a guilty verdict last week for the deaths of Birchmore and her unborn child. The juror noted he followed other major Massachusetts cases, including those of Karen Read and Lindsay Clancy, but entered the Farwell trial with little prior knowledge of the specific details.






