Susan Smith Faces Parole Board Again 32 Years After Drowning Her Sons
The 55-year-old woman, who is serving life in prison for the 1994 deaths of her children, will appear via video conference Thursday seeking release under South Carolina law.
By Yuki Melnyk ·

Susan Smith will appear before a state parole board Thursday, marking her second attempt at freedom since being sentenced to life in prison for the 1994 drowning of her two young sons. Smith, now 55, will join the hearing by video link from prison, where she has remained for more than three decades.
The case, which became an international phenomenon in the mid-1990s, saw Smith roll her Mazda into John D. Long Lake in Union County while her children, Michael, age 3, and Alex, age 14 months, were strapped into their car seats. A jury convicted her of murder but spared her the death penalty, resulting in a life sentence under the state’s parole eligibility rules.
Under the laws in effect at the time of her sentencing, Smith became eligible to petition for parole after 30 years. When the board unanimously denied her request in 2024, the rules allowed her to reapply every two years thereafter. This Thursday’s hearing is her first retry since that initial denial.
David Smith, the boys’ father, plans to travel to Columbia early in the morning to oppose his ex-wife’s release again. He vowed at the 2024 hearing to fight her parole for as long as he is alive. The original prosecutors in the case will also be present to argue for her continued incarceration. Smith is expected to wear the same photograph of her sons that gained global attention during the initial search for the children.
The state Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services oversees the process. Smith needs the support of at least five of the seven board members to secure her release. The board’s track record suggests the odds are low; agency statistics show it granted parole in only 4% of the cases it reviewed, with most approvals going to inmates with non-violent records.
During the original trial, prosecutors argued that Smith killed her sons because she believed they caused the end of an affair with a wealthy man who worked where she was employed. Her defense team, meanwhile, focused on her mental state, claiming she intended to drive into the lake with her children but hesitated at the last second. Her lawyer is expected to make similar arguments, emphasizing her lack of other criminal history and low risk of reoffending.
At her first parole hearing in 2024, Smith appealed to the board on religious and emotional grounds. She stated that God had forgiven her and asked for the same mercy. She described the act as horrible and said she would give anything to have her sons back.
The 1994 case began with Smith claiming for nine days that a Black carjacker had abducted her children. Her account, which played into widespread fears about crime and race at the time, collapsed when she eventually confessed. Investigators later re-created the accident, determining it took six minutes for the car to sink. Interior cameras captured water entering through the vents and rising steadily before the boys’ bodies were recovered upside-down in their seats.
The hearing will be conducted virtually, with Smith participating from her prison facility. The board will deliberate after hearing arguments from the family, prosecutors, and Smith’s legal team. A decision on her parole request is not expected until after the session concludes.






