Rockaway Beach Board Members Vote to Table Motion for Chair’s Resignation
Internal conflict at Community Board 14 delayed a zoning decision and forced a vote on the board’s annual budget amid disputes over leadership.
By Yuki Melnyk ·

A motion for Dolores Orr to step down as Chair of Community Board 14 was tabled until December after a contentious meeting on Tuesday night. The vote to delay the decision followed a series of interruptions and public disputes that overshadowed the board’s standard agenda items. Second Vice-Chair Rose Marie Duggan-Gulston introduced the motion during the old business segment, stating she lacked trust in Orr’s leadership.
The friction between the executive team had been building for weeks. Duggan-Gulston and Fourth Vice-Chair David Shelborne expressed dissatisfaction with the management style of Orr and District Manager Felicia Johnson. Duggan-Gulston stood from her seat early in the meeting to complain that she had not been recognized as Second Vice-Chair on the board’s website for several months. Orr responded by telling her she was out of order and striking her gavel multiple times. Duggan-Gulston continued to speak until she was asked to sit down.
Tensions rose again during the discussion of the district’s budget recommendations. The vote was intended to be a simple affirmation of a previous decision. However, Duggan-Gulston announced she would vote no because she served on the Budget Committee but had not received an invitation to the committee meeting. Shelborne joined the critique, raising concerns about specific management decisions made by the district office.
During the final phase of the debate, Duggan-Gulston listed a series of actions she described as personal bias or discrimination. She formally moved for Orr to resign. Board member Damara Lee suggested the board hold a private executive team meeting to resolve the issues rather than airing them in public. Orr and Johnson argued that some complaints were operational errors or items outside the district’s control. Samuel Jaroslawicz raised points of order regarding the motion and the lack of a quorum. Duggan-Gulston agreed to table the motion until the December meeting.
The board completed its scheduled business despite the internal conflict. Members voted to reject an upzoning request from the owners of 228 Beach 87 St. in Rockaway Beach. Land Use Committee Chairman John Cori cited community concerns about the proposed building height of 115 feet, flooding risks, school capacity, and sanitation. Representatives Richard Lobel and Kevin Conte presented counterarguments to address those concerns. The board voted overwhelmingly to reject the zoning change, with only two members affirming the proposal.
The board also approved its annual budget recommendations by a vote of 17 to 4, with seven abstentions. Several members abstained in solidarity with Duggan-Gulston and Shelborne. The vote concluded the formal agenda for the month.
Other items from the meeting included a report from the 101st Precinct. Commanding Officer George Ng stated that 17 additional police officers would be assigned to the precinct beginning November 11. A crime prevention officer warned residents about package theft during the holiday season. The Department of Transportation is scheduled to appear at the January meeting to discuss parking rules on Shore Front Parkway. A citizen noted that the Arverne East Nature Preserve Welcome Center now requires insurance for room bookings, a cost that may hinder smaller civic groups. The MCU is holding a ribbon-cutting ceremony at its Arverne location on November 19.






